By Chuck Collins | –
(Institute for Policy Studies) – Sen. Wyden’s billionaires income tax tapping those huge returns could raise big revenue to fund President Biden’s Build Back Better investment plan.
America’s billionaires have grown $2.1 trillion richer during the pandemic, their collective fortune skyrocketing by 70 percent—from just short of $3 trillion at the start of the COVID crisis on March 18, 2020, to over $5 trillion on October 15 of this year, according to Forbes data analyzed by Americans for Tax Fairness (ATF) and the Institute for Policy Studies Program on Inequality (IPS). [A table of the top 15 billionaires is below.]
Not only did the wealth of U.S. billionaires grow, but so did their numbers: in March of last year, there were 614 with 10-figure bank accounts; this October, there are 745.
The $5 trillion in wealth now held by 745 billionaires is two-thirds more than the $3 trillion in wealth held by the bottom 50 percent of U.S. households estimated by the Federal Reserve Board.
The great good fortune of these billionaires over the past 19 months is all the more stark when contrasted with the devastating impact of coronavirus on working people. Almost 89 million Americans have lost jobs, over 44.9 million have been sickened by the virus, and over 724,000 have died from it.
To put this extraordinary wealth growth in perspective, the $2.1 trillion gain over 19 months by U.S. billionaires is equal to:
- 60 percent of the $3.5 trillion ten-year cost of President Biden’s Build Back Better plan.
- The entire $2.1 trillion in new revenues over ten years approved by the House Ways and Means Committee to help pay for President Biden’s Build Back Better (BBB) investment plan.
Sixty-seven national organizations have sent a letter to Congress expressing concern that neither the Ways and Means committee plan nor President Biden’s plan will adequately tax billionaires. They recommend Billionaires Income Tax (BIT) legislation under development by Sen. Ron Wyden, chairman of the Finance Committee, be included in final BBB legislation. It is also supported by President Biden.
Most of these huge billionaires’ gains will go untaxed under current rules and will disappear entirely for tax purposes when they’re passed onto the next generation. Under Wyden’s BIT, billionaires will start paying taxes on their increased wealth each year just like workers pay taxes on their paychecks each year.
The tax will apply only to taxpayers whose wealth exceeds $1 billion: about 700 households. It will be assessed annually on tradable assets, such as stocks, where the value of the asset is known at the beginning and end of the year. For non-tradable assets, such as ownership in a business or real estate holdings, taxes will be deferred until the asset is sold.
Public support for the Billionaire Income Tax is very strong. When proposed as a way to pay for President Biden’s $3.5 trillion investment package it increases support 20 to 40 points among voters in battleground districts and states.
| Name | Net Worth
Mar. 18, 2020 ($ Billions) |
Net Worth
Oct. 15, 2021 ($ Billions) |
19 Month
Wealth Growth ($ Billions) |
19 Month
Percent Wealth Growth |
Source |
| Elon Musk | $24.6 | $209.4 | $184.8 | 751.0% | Tesla, SpaceX |
| Jeff Bezos | $113.0 | $192.2 | $79.2 | 70.1% | Amazon |
| Bill Gates | $98.0 | $132.4 | $34.4 | 35.1% | Microsoft |
| Larry Ellison | $59.0 | $124.5 | $65.5 | 111.1% | software |
| Larry Page | $50.9 | $120.7 | $69.8 | 137.2% | |
| Mark Zuckerberg | $54.7 | $117.6 | $62.9 | 114.9% | |
| Sergey Brin | $49.1 | $116.3 | $67.2 | 136.9% | |
| Warren Buffett | $67.5 | $102.2 | $34.7 | 51.4% | Berkshire Hathaway |
| Steve Ballmer | $52.7 | $96.9 | $44.2 | 83.9% | Microsoft |
| Jim Walton | $54.6 | $65.4 | $10.8 | 19.8% | Walmart |
| Alice Walton | $54.4 | $64.5 | $10.1 | 18.5% | Walmart |
| Rob Walton | $54.1 | $64.2 | $10.1 | 18.6% | Walmart |
| Michael Bloomberg | $48.0 | $59.0 | $11.0 | 22.9% | Bloomberg LP |
| Phil Knight | $29.5 | $57.9 | $28.4 | 96.4% | Nike |
| MacKenzie Scott | $36.0 | $55.5 | $19.5 | 54.1% | Amazon |
| SUBTOTAL | $846.1 | $1,578.7 | $732.6 | 86.6% | |
| ALL OTHERS | $2,101.4 | $3,440.7 | $1,339.3 | 63.7% | |
| U.S. TOTAL | $2,947.5 | $5,019.4 | $2,071.9 | 70.3% |
Sources: March 18, 2020 data: Forbes, “
Among the individual stories behind the big numbers:
- Elon Musk of Tesla and SpaceX fame is not only beating Jeff Bezos in space, he has rocketed past him in the billionaires club. Nineteen months ago, Bezos was nearly five times richer than Musk. Now, after a meteoric eight-fold increase in his wealth, Musk is worth $209 billion and Bezos $192 billion. Bezos’s wealth still grew by a very large 70 percent over the period.
- Google founders Sergei Brin and Larry Page are now worth $237 billion combined, a 137 percent increase from their combined wealth of $100 billion at the beginning of the pandemic.
- Nike head Phil Knight has nearly doubled his fortune from $29.5 billion to almost $58 billion. Maybe that’s in part because Nike didn’t pay a dime of federal income taxes in 2020 on its $2.9 billion in profits; and between 2018 and 2020 the corporation paid just a 3.3 percent tax rate on $9 billion in profits.
- MacKenzie Scott, former wife of Amazon founder Jeff Bezos, saw her wealth increase $19.5 billion, or 54 percent, since the pandemic began even after giving away $8.6 billion of her wealth to charity
BILLIONAIRES UNDERTAXED
America’s billionaire bonanza demonstrates the structural flaws in our current economic and tax systems President Biden and Democrats in Congress are trying to remedy by advancing a $3.5 trillion package of investments in working families and communities, paid for with fairer taxes on the rich and corporations.
On average, billionaires pay an effective federal income tax rate of about 8 percent when the increased value of their stock is counted, according to the White House. This is a lower rate than many middle-income taxpayers pay like teachers, nurses and firefighters.
Billionaires pay such low tax rates because:
- Most of their income comes from the increased value of their investments such as stocks, a business or real estate, rather than a paycheck like most people, and they don’t have to pay taxes on that increased wealth unless they sell the assets. But the ultra-rich don’t need to sell assets. Instead, because of the size of their fortunes, they can borrow money at low rates from banks and live lavishly tax free.
- When they sell their assets they pay a top capital gains tax rate of 20 percent (plus a 3.8 percent net investment income tax, NIIT) far below the current 37 percent (40.8 percent) top rate they would pay on an equivalent salary. This is why many ultra-rich pay a lower tax rate than people in the middle class.
According to ProPublica’s analysis of IRS data:
- Billionaires have paid no federal income taxes in some recent years, including Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Michael Bloomberg and George Soros.
- The country’s 25 top billionaires paid a tax rate of just 3.4 percent on a $400 billion increase in their collective fortune between 2014-18.
Poll after poll shows that Americans of all political persuasions and by large majorities believe that the wealthy and big corporations need to start paying their fair share of taxes. A June poll by ALG Research and Hart Research shows 62 percent of voters support Biden’s proposed $4 trillion (at the time) investments in healthcare, childcare, education, clean energy and more—paid for by higher taxes on the rich and corporations.
A Note on Data: We draw on data from Forbes research on billionaire wealth. Thanks to Kerry Dolan and her team. Why March 18? March 18, 2020 is used as the unofficial beginning of the coronavirus crisis because by then most federal and state economic restrictions responding to the virus were in place. March 18 was also the date that Forbes picked to measure billionaire wealth for the 2020 edition of its annual global billionaires’ report, which provided a baseline that ATF and HCAN compare periodically with real-time data from the Forbes website. PolitiFact has favorably reviewed this methodology.
Chuck Collins is the Director of the Program on Inequality and the Common Good at the Institute for Policy Studies, where he co-edits Inequality.org. He is author of the popular book, Born on Third Base: A One Percenter Makes the Case for Tackling Inequality, Bringing Wealth Home, and Committing to the Common Good (Chelsea Green). His most recent book is The Wealth Hoarders: How Billionaires Spend Millions to Hide Trillions (Polity Books). He is an expert on U.S. inequality and the racial wealth divide and author of several other books, including with Bill Gates Sr. of Wealth and Our Commonwealth, (Beacon Press, 2003), a case for taxing inherited fortunes. He is co-author with Mary Wright of The Moral Measure of the Economy, a book about Christian ethics and economic life. He was featured in this interview in Sun Magazine and with Terry Gross on NPR’s Fresh Air.
Via Institute for Policy Studies
—
Bonus Video added by Informed Comment:
America’s 400 Wealthiest Billionaires Are Worth $4.5 Trillion In 2021 | Forbes
© 2024 All Rights Reserved